Is There Broth in Your Bone Broth?!

Bone broth may be one of the oldest foods consumed by man, but it’s recently experienced a resurgence in popularity. And, as we’ve seen with Greek yogurt, chia, and gluten-free – when something gets popular, companies are quick to jump on the buzzword bandwagon to try and make a buck.

Exhibit A:  

gluten free lap dances

This would seem like a good thing – more healthy products for more people, right?

Unfortunately, not so much. Many companies are more concerned with profit than product. They rush to market, cutting corners on quality (not to mention integrity) in order to save money and/or get their wares on shelves faster. Additionally, the faster you bring a product to market, the fewer legal regulations you have to deal with.

Some food trends appear so fast,
the government doesn’t have time to create clear labeling laws.

 This creates a situation where, if a company moves quickly, they can package a product, printing whatever they want on the label, and sell hundreds, if not thousands, of units before the government has time to catch up. Here is where we find ourselves with bone broth.

Currently, there is no USDA or FDA definition for bone broth.
Bone broth USDA regulations
Companies can pretty much call anything bone broth and get away with it.


Is Your 'Bone Broth' Really Stock?

The first sneaky trick companies have come up with is to package regular broth or stock as bone broth.

What’s the difference between broth, stock, and bone broth?

Broth is made by simmering water, vegetables, herbs, spices, and meat for 45 minutes to 2 hours. Broth can include some bones, but it’s mostly meat.

Stock is made by simmering water, vegetables, herbs, spices, with more bones than meat. It’s also cooked longer – usually 4 to 6 hours. Chicken stock tends to have a fuller mouth feel and richer flavor, due to the fact that some of the collagen in the bones is released into the water during the cooking process.

Bone broth is like SUPER stock. It’s traditionally made by slow-simmering water, ONLY bones – no meat – and apple cider vinegar for no less than 18 hours. This amount of time allows the bones to fully break down and release their structural components, including collagen, glucosamine, chondroitin, and minerals, into the water.  When the collagen is cooled it turns into gelatin.

You can tell a broth is full of collagen if it turns to gel when it’s cooled.
bone broth gel

Is There Filler Broth In Your Bone Broth?

The second, and, we think, more devious trick is adding broth to bone broth.   


Exhibit C: 

bone broth ingredients

Some brands (who shall remain nameless) add pre-made broth – which could be in the form of a powdered base, such as boullion or powdered chicken parts – to their broth.

Why would they do this? To be honest, we’re not really sure. Our best guess is that by adding pre-made broth (or “filler broth”) to their bone broth, these companies can speed the cooking process, change the flavor, and/or make more broth for less money. 

They can make more broth, cheaper and faster. 

How Can I Make Sure My Bone Broth Is Legit?

1. Head to the Freezer Aisle

When buying bone broth from the store, the first step is to head to the freezer aisle. Bone broth has always traditionally been stored by freezing – this preserves nutrients at their peak. If a bone broth is sold frozen, that’s usually a good indication that the company understands and values the traditional method of making bone broth.

2. Read the ingredients – carefully!

Companies can get pretty crafty with wording, especially since bone broth is a new product category with no regulated definition.  

If you see something strange, like broth listed twice, do some research on the brand and the product. Reach out to the company. Any brand worth their sea salt should be able to give you a good reason (in plain English) as to why they’re using certain ingredients.

True Bone Broth. Traditionally Made.

At Bonafide Provisions, we pride ourselves on making what we call, “true” bone broth – that’s bone broth made the way our ancestors made it.

We use ONLY bones.
(Grass-fed and pasture-raised, of course.)
We slow-simmer for no less than 18 hours.
We freeze our broth.
We are certified organic.

We also didn’t hop on the bone broth bandwagon yesterday. We started making bone broth almost 15 years ago, in 2005, when our founder, Sharon – a Clinical Nutritionist, NTP, and GAPS practitioner – used bone broth to heal her son’s chronic illness and treat thousands of nutrition clients across North America. Read Sharon’s story. 

Don't Mess With Your Food & It Won't Mess With You

We are on a mission to bring abundant wellness to the world. We believe that there is wisdom in tradition and it is our promise to you to stay as true as possible to the time-tested, time-honored cooking methods of our ancestors.

FYI: Our Frontier Blend is not certified organic – yet! We are in the process of getting certification, which takes time. Our recipe currently includes all organic ingredients with the exception of our lamb and bison bones, which are grass-fed and grass-finished and our Celtic sea salt, which comes from the sea (and can't really be certified organic.) 

If you ever have any questions about how we do things, please don’t hesitate to ask! 


Thank you for the information and sharing in detail to inform us in staying health & being truthful, many blessings for your success in the product you provide.

Carrie Camp September 01, 2020

Thank You from the bottom of my heart for providing this life-giving, healing and comforting real FOOD from the ancients! It is keeping me well and healthy in so many ways. I was sick. Now I am not!

I love your mission statement. There are some things about the “old days/old ways” that should be respected and left untouched. Can’t improve on a sure thing!

Blessings on your husband, you and your son. Thanks for following your GUT! Haha! literally!

Rhonda H March 11, 2019

I love you bone broth. Thank you for all that you do.

Joseph Pia March 11, 2019

How is it delivered? Does it come frozen?

Djhoanna B Piolo July 22, 2019

Is the organic bone broth in the brown and red bag grass fed AND grass finished? I’m not seeing it anywhere on the bag or here in the info. If it is, I would like to see it on the bag that it is also grass finished. But it is delicious and I’d like to continue buying it but I don’t want bones from beef that has been finished with soy, corn, etc.

Thanks so much for your response.


Carol July 22, 2019

Leave a comment

All comments are moderated before being published

“I started drinking bone broth a few years back when I was desperate to get my health back in order. It’s now a staple in our home… On the weeks where I am feeling a little less inclined to make my own, I really enjoy @bonafideprovisions.”

— Krista Happ @KristaHapp